How Do I Claim Diminished Value for My Car Insurance? You can make a diminished value car insurance claim with the insurer of the driver who hit you, but you must first prove the accident reduced your car’s value.

If your car sustains damage in an accident that someone else caused, their insurance company traditionally pays for the necessary repairs. However, even if the repairs return your vehicle to like-new condition, its value may diminish. The legal term for this phenomenon is “diminution,” or the diminishing of monetary value.

Under Florida law, a vehicle owner can pursue a claim for diminution from the negligent party, typically by filing directly with their insurance company. However, to make this claim, you must provide clear proof of the diminution and its dollar value. The car accident lawyers at the Law Offices of Anidjar & Levine can help prove your claim for diminished value and other damages. Call us today for a free case evaluation at (954) 525-0050.

For a free legal consultation, call (800) 747-3733

What is Diminished Value in a Car Insurance Claim?

After a car crash, even once your car repairs are complete, your vehicle’s market value diminishes as compared to the identical vehicle that never sustained damage in an accident. Thus, diminution can make it challenging for you to sell your car now that its resale value has fallen because it has been in an accident.

The reasons a car’s value diminishes after an accident primarily relates to safety and the subsequent buyer’s concerns about value. If you are pursuing a diminished value car insurance claim, your situation may fall into one of three categories:

  • Immediate diminished value: This concerns the difference in the car’s value right before and right after the accident occurs. It refers to the difference between how much the car would be worth if you traded it in or tried to sell it immediately after a crash. This is the most common scenario among claims of this type.
  • Inherent diminished value: This category of diminished value concerns what the car was worth before an accident and what it is worth after you have it repaired. Even if it has received top-notch repairs, a car is perceived to be less reliable or safe, so its value drops due to its accident history.
  • Repair-related diminished value: A car’s reduced value in this category refers to the repair’s quality or the quality of the parts used to fix the vehicle after an accident.

The Stigma of an ‘Accident Car’ can make Resale Tough

Used car buyers often avoid buying an “accident car,” as many vehicle history reporting services call them. If there is evidence of towing on a car history report, buyers inherently fear a serious accident and extensive damages.

Consumers understand that insurance companies do not like paying claims, and unethical auto repair shops sometimes take shortcuts. So, even if your vehicle underwent the highest quality of repairs, a buyer may be unwilling to take that chance.

You Could Even Have Problems Trading Your Vehicle

Even if you plan to trade your vehicle in at the dealership rather than sell it yourself, the dealer knows that a formerly wrecked vehicle carries a stigma that makes it a tough sell — and worth significantly less than an equivalent vehicle that did not sustain damage in an accident.

Click to contact our personal injury lawyers today

Who is Responsible for Paying Your Diminished Value Claim?

The Florida statutes addressing the settlement of motor vehicle claims give legal standing to a vehicle owner to pursue a diminished value claim from an at-fault driver (or that driver’s insurance company.)

Complete a Free Case Evaluation form now

How do you Prove Diminished Value in a Car Insurance Claim?

Depending on the make, model, year, and amenities, the diminished value of your vehicle could be many thousands of dollars. In Florida, the plaintiff (claimant) carries the burden of proving the diminished value of their vehicle. This means that you (and your car accident lawyer, if you have one) must document your vehicle’s diminution.

Proving diminution can present a significant challenge, especially to a vehicle owner. Some collision damage repair shops can provide an estimate of value for your car with and without having undergone damage and repair. However, the insurance company may not accept this assessment.

We Can Consult with Experts on Your Car’s Value

Ideally, you can call on a certified vehicle appraiser or another recognized industry expert to handle the research for you. These professionals have extensive knowledge of vehicle markets, particularly in your area, as well as the ability to analyze collision damage and the quality of completed repairs.

Car accident lawyers have access to such subject matter experts if you struggle to find someone who can verify your diminution to the insurance company’s satisfaction.

How can a Florida Car Accident Lawyer Help You?

Car accident lawyers work daily to help their clients recover damages sustained in Florida car accidents, including car repair and diminished value claims.

Contact the Law Offices of Anidjar & Levine today at (954) 525-0050 to learn more. You can schedule a no-cost consultation to speak to one of our Florida car accident lawyers, who help you determine if you have a valid diminished value car insurance claim.