If you are in the midst of a Jacksonville car accident case, you may be wondering about the difference between a settlement and a trial in Jacksonville car accident cases. A settlement is a negotiated agreement that resolves the case, while a trial is a formal legal proceeding where a judge or jury decides the outcome.
Not every car accident case goes to trial. However, if the insurance company doesn’t offer a fair settlement, you may need to take your case to court. A Jacksonville car accident lawyer can help determine the best course of action and fight for the compensation you are entitled to.
The Difference Between a Settlement and a Trial in a Car Accident Case
A settlement is a negotiated resolution between you and the insurance company. A trial, on the other hand, is a formal legal proceeding where a judge or jury decides the outcome. Both can compensate you for your injuries, but they involve very different processes.
A settlement allows both sides to avoid the uncertainty and time commitment of court. You agree on an amount, sign the paperwork, and receive payment. A trial, on the other hand, involves presenting evidence, calling witnesses, and letting a judge or jury determine liability and damages.
Most cases settle because insurance companies want to limit risk, and injured victims often want to avoid delays. But if the insurer refuses to make a fair offer, going to trial may be the only way to secure fair compensation.
Why Most Jacksonville Car Accident Cases Settle
Insurance companies are in the business of minimizing payouts, but they also dislike the unpredictability of courts. Trials can result in significantly higher awards than settlements. Because of this, both sides usually find common ground before a trial becomes necessary.
Settlements also save time. A trial can take a year or longer, while a settlement may be reached in a matter of months.
Why Some Jacksonville Car Accident Cases Go to Trial
Not every claim is resolved through a settlement. Common reasons a case ends up in court include:
- Liability disputes: The insurer claims their driver wasn’t at fault or argues that you contributed to the crash.
- Lowball offers: The insurance company refuses to offer enough to cover your losses.
- Serious injuries: High-value cases often face more pushback.
- Bad–faith tactics: The insurer delays, denies, or mishandles your claim.
Trials take longer and involve more uncertainty, but they also give you the chance to obtain the full value of your damages if the evidence is on your side.
Pros and Cons of Settling Your Car Accident Case
Settlements come with advantages, but they also have limitations. The benefits of agreeing to a settlement include:
- Faster resolution: You can receive your compensation much sooner than if you went to trial.
- Lower stress: There’s no court testimony, no waiting for verdicts, and no appeals.
- More predictable outcome: You know exactly how much you are receiving, rather than gambling on a jury decision.
- No risk of losing: Trials always carry the possibility of walking away with nothing.
The downside is that a settlement may be less than what a jury might award. Insurance companies count on victims taking smaller amounts in exchange for a quicker payout.
Pros and Cons of Taking Your Case to Trial
Trials can maximize your recovery, but they also come with challenges. The upsides include:
- Potential for higher compensation: Juries can award substantial damages, especially in cases with clear negligence or severe injuries.
- Public accountability: A trial exposes negligent behavior and forces the defendant to answer for their actions.
- Stronger leverage: Insurance companies may increase their offers when they know you are willing to take a case to court.
But trials have drawbacks, including a longer timeline, stressful court appearances, and the possibility of losing and walking away with nothing.
What Happens During the Settlement Process?
If your case is headed toward settlement, here’s what the timeline usually looks like:
- Your lawyer investigates the crash and gathers evidence.
- You complete treatment or reach maximum medical improvement.
- Your lawyer prepares a demand package outlining your losses.
- The insurance company reviews it and responds with an offer.
- Both sides negotiate until you agree on an amount.
- You sign a release, and the insurer sends payment.
Settlements rely heavily on documentation of damages. The stronger your evidence is, the better your chances of securing a fair offer will be.
What Happens During a Trial?
If your case goes to trial, you can expect the following stages:
- Filing a lawsuit: Your attorney submits a formal complaint.
- Discovery: Both sides exchange evidence and take depositions.
- Motions: The court resolves disputes before trial begins.
- Jury selection: A panel is chosen to hear the case.
- Opening statements: Each side outlines its position.
- Presentation of evidence: Witnesses testify and are cross-examined.
- Closing arguments: Both sides summarize their cases.
- Jury deliberation: The jury reaches a verdict on fault and damages.
- Judgment: The court issues the final ruling.
This process is slow, but it allows you to present every detail of your case and hold the insurance company accountable.
When Should You Consider Settling?
It may be wise to settle if:
- The insurer makes a reasonable offer.
- You want to avoid the time and unpredictability of court.
- You need compensation quickly.
An attorney can help you decide whether agreeing to a settlement is in your best interests.
When Should You Consider Going to Trial?
Going to trial may be the best move if:
- The insurance company refuses to take your damages seriously.
- Your injuries are severe or permanent.
- The other party’s liability is clear and well-supported by evidence.
- The insurer’s offers are far below your actual losses.
Your attorney will advise you based on the strength of the evidence and the value of your case.
Speak to a Car Accident Lawyer in Jacksonville
The difference between settling and going to trial in a Jacksonville car accident case comes down to control, timing, and risk. Settlements offer faster, predictable outcomes, while trials offer the chance for higher compensation but with more uncertainty.
A Jacksonville car accident attorney from Anidjar & Levine can help decide which is best for your case.
Schedule a free consultation to discuss your situation with a lawyer.
We Can Help.
